Olive_Branch_Facility_Manufacturing_Capabilities_Banner.jpg

Vertical Lineshaft Turbine versus Submersible Turbine Pumps: Which is Better for my Application?

Choosing between a vertical lineshaft turbine and a submersible turbine pump can have a significant impact on system performance, installation and long-term maintenance. While both pump types are commonly used for deep wells, reservoirs and industrial water systems, they differ in configuration, installation requirements, serviceability and operating characteristics. Understanding the differences is key to selecting the right pump for the application.

Pros of a Vertical Lineshaft Turbine Pump

Easier motor access and service: Vertical lineshaft turbine pump motors are installed above ground, with a long shaft connecting the motor to the impellers below. This keeps the motor dry and accessible for inspection, maintenance and service. Many motors are also rewindable, helping support a long service life with proper maintenance. By comparison, servicing a submersible motor typically requires pulling the pump and motor from the well. Additionally, some submersible motors may not be rewindable, though there are options to install rewindable motors for many submersible turbine pumps.

Higher flow capabilities: For applications requiring very high flow rates, vertical lineshaft turbine pumps provide greater capacity. Franklin Electric vertical lineshaft turbine pumps are available with bowl sizes up to 42 inches and flow rates up to 40,000 GPM, while submersible turbine bowl sizes are available up to 12 inches. This makes vertical lineshaft turbines well suited for high-capacity water pumping applications.

Submersible_vs_VLT_Blog_Post_Copy_Image.png

Well suited for top-feed wells and open-water applications: Because the motor of a vertical lineshaft turbine pump is located above ground and air-cooled, motor cooling does not depend on water flowing past the motor. This can make vertical lineshaft turbines a strong choice for top-feed wells and open-water applications. Submersible motors rely on adequate water flow for cooling and may require a flow sleeve in applications where sufficient flow past the motor cannot be maintained.

Pros of a Submersible Turbine Pump

Quieter operation: Because the motor operates below the water level, submersible turbine pumps typically produce less above-ground noise than vertical lineshaft turbines. This makes them well suited for applications where noise levels are a concern, including golf courses, residential areas and other locations where pumping equipment is installed near people.

Simpler installation and routine maintenance: Submersible turbine pumps have fewer above-ground components and moving parts, which can simplify initial installation and reduce routine maintenance requirements. Vertical lineshaft turbines provide easier access to the motor, but installation can be more involved due to shaft alignment and pre-lubrication requirements for the lineshaft and bearings.

Smaller surface footprint: With the pump and motor installed below the water level, submersible turbine pumps require less equipment at the surface. Their compact above-ground footprint makes them a practical choice where installation space is limited or where a lower-profile pumping system is preferred.

Better suited for misaligned wells: Submersible turbine pumps can be a better choice for wells that are not completely straight or plumb. Vertical lineshaft turbines require proper alignment to avoid excessive wear or damage to the shaft, bearings and other components. A plumbness test may be required before installing a vertical lineshaft turbine to verify that the well casing can accommodate the pump assembly.

Other Key Factors When Choosing Between Vertical Lineshaft and Submersible Turbine Pumps

Initial and long-term costs: Pump cost depends on several factors, including set depth, motor horsepower and system configuration. For lower-horsepower applications, a submersible system may offer a lower initial equipment cost. At higher horsepower, a vertical lineshaft turbine motor may be more cost-effective. Permanent magnet submersible motors can also improve operating efficiency, potentially reducing electricity costs over the life of the system.

Backup power requirements: Consider how the pumping system will operate during a power outage. Vertical lineshaft turbines equipped with a gear drive can be paired with a diesel engine for backup operation. Generator power can also be used with electrically-driven vertical lineshaft and submersible turbine systems.

Subersible_vs_VLT_Blog_Post_16-9.jpg

Flow requirements: Required flow rate can be a key factor when selecting between the two pump types. Submersible turbines typically operate at higher speeds, allowing them to deliver substantial flow from a smaller-diameter pump. Vertical lineshaft turbines can accommodate larger bowl assemblies, making them well suited for applications requiring very high flow rates.

Well depth and application requirements: Set depth alone does not determine which pump is the better choice. Horsepower, installation requirements, efficiency and regional well characteristics should also be considered. In deeper, lower-horsepower applications, a submersible turbine may provide a simpler and more cost-effective installation. For deeper, higher-horsepower systems, a vertical lineshaft turbine may offer advantages in efficiency, capacity and serviceability.

Motor efficiency: Motor efficiency can significantly affect long-term operating costs, particularly in high-horsepower or high-duty-cycle applications. Above-ground vertical lineshaft turbine motors can achieve efficiencies above 90%. Permanent magnet submersible motors can also exceed 90% efficiency, providing another high-efficiency option where a submersible configuration is preferred.

System control and protection: Both vertical lineshaft and submersible turbine pumps can be paired with a variable frequency drive (VFD) for greater control and system protection. A VFD provides soft-start capabilities that reduce inrush current and mechanical stress at startup while allowing operators to monitor parameters such as voltage, amperage and pressure. Depending on the drive, remote monitoring and fault notifications can also help identify operating issues before pump or motor damage occurs.

A reduced-voltage soft starter provides a more basic alternative when variable-speed control is not required. By limiting voltage and inrush current during startup, a soft starter reduces starting torque and mechanical stress on system components. Reduced-voltage starting may also be required by the electric utility or local requirements for motors above certain horsepower levels.

Choosing the Right Turbine Pump for Your Application

Choosing between a vertical lineshaft turbine pump and a submersible turbine pump comes down to the requirements of the application. Flow rate, well depth, horsepower, motor efficiency, installation requirements, available space, maintenance access and backup power can all influence which pump configuration provides the best fit.

Vertical lineshaft turbine pumps can be well suited for high-flow applications where above-ground motor access and serviceability are priorities. Submersible turbine pumps offer a compact, quieter configuration that can simplify installation and accommodate a wider range of well conditions. Evaluating these factors as part of the complete pumping system can help engineers select a solution that delivers reliable performance, efficient operation and long-term value.

Franklin Electric offers a wide selection of both types of pumps, delivering flows up to 40,000 gallons per minute with heads that can go up to 2,500 feet deep.

Find the right pump for your application using FE Select:

< All News
Who We Are

Franklin Electric is a global leader in the production and marketing of systems and components for the movement of water and energy. Recognized as a technical leader in its products and services, Franklin Electric serves customers worldwide in residential, commercial, agricultural, industrial, municipal, and fueling applications. Franklin Electric is proud to be recognized in Newsweek’s lists of America’s Most Responsible Companies 2024, Most Trustworthy Companies 2024, and Greenest Companies 2025; Best Places to Work in Indiana 2024; and America’s Climate Leaders 2024 by USA Today.